Keuka Lake Cottage For Sale – The Parsonage

The Parsonage has an accepted offer on it and should close in the near future. This change occurred on 12/29/2013


If you have ever taken a boat ride around Keuka Lake, then the Parsonage is most likely one of the cottages you remembered seeing,


Vintage cottage

It is one of those rare vintage cottages that has not been removed and replaced with a McMansion. It is a place that brings back memories of visiting family or friends at the lake.  It was a place of fun, where you would hear the sound of the screen door shutting each time you ran through the doors, and no one would care.

This inviting, comfortable and adorable cottage is back on the market, offered at $459,000.  It comes with 200 feet of private lakefront and several building that offer 4 bedrooms, 1 full bath and 1 half bath.  It was built in 1883 and still carries a timeless charm.  It has been updated to public sewers and public water is available.

What a great porch to take a nap on, munch on a peanut butter sandwich or learn to play chess with Uncle Ed.

keuka lake realtor

Old maps hanging on the walls, an assortment of coffee cups in a row and fresh flowers on the table – vintage cottage indeed !

Mary St.George #1 keuka realtor

Simple white curtains,  fishing poles lined up against a wall and garage sale finds with plenty of books to read, are all requisite staples of a comfy cottage.

keuka lake

Snuggling into beds adorned with nice light coverings completed a fun filled day all the way into dreamland.

This cottage located at 8809 East Bluff Dr , Penn Yan, NY on Keuka Lake is available to view.  To see this unique home of 1220 sq ft  filled with unending character, give me a call.  It is priced to sell and will mostly likely not be around for very long.

Can’t you picture yourself here, locked away from the hustle and bustle of everyday living, just learning to love life again?

Listing information courtesy of GRAR MLS R179681 , brought to you by Mary St.George, Associate Broker, Wine Trail Properties, Your Personal Connection to Lakefront Living, 315-719-8377,[email protected]

  1. Al Lauger

    Is this property still for sale? Or did it sell?

  2. Mary St. George

    Al this property now has an accepted offer on it. Would like information on other vintage cottages for sale ?

Leave a Reply

Copyright © 2007 Buying and Selling Waterfront Properties in the Finger Lakes     Agent Login     Design by Real Estate Tomato     Powered by Tomato Blogs

Mary St. George